Understanding design and performance of high performance structured packing

High performance structured packings have been on the market for around 10 years. They continue to gain market share because of their high capacity and excellent efficiency. This is especially true in vacuum tower applications where pressure drop is critical. High performance packings can yield substantial savings in capital and operating costs with increased capacity and lower flash zone pressure and temperature.

Packing Design Fundamentals
One of the fundamental characteristics of structured packings is that they have their greatest advantage in high vapor rate and low liquid rate applications. Structured packings take up very little cross section space within the column (around 1%) and allow vapor to flow through them in a continuous phase. In distillation systems, where liquid and vapor rates are dependant, vacuum applications have huge volumetric vapor flows. In high pressure distillation applications, the vapor volume may be 10 times greater than liquid volume, but in vacuum applications, the vapor volume may be over 10,000 times greater than the liquid volume. In these cases, the column internals must be able to efficiently handle these very large vapor flows. The open design of structured packings allow them to very effectively do just that.

High performance structured packings have the same operational characteristics as the standard packings only the high vapor handling capability is even more pronounced. For example, testing at Fractionation Research Inc. (FRISM), showed that Mellapak- PlusTM 252.Y showed approximately 20% more useful capacity than standard MellapakTM 250.Y at 23.5 psia but showed fully 40% more useful capacity under vacuum conditions of 75 mm Hg. Because of this proven benefit, high performance structured packings can be used in commercial vacuum applications to allow significantly smaller column diameters and/or lower pressure drops and column flash zone pressures.

High performance structured packings achieve better results because they provide a smoother transition for the liquid and vapor to pass vertically between adjacent packing layers. With conventional structured packing, the discontinuity between 45o corrugated packing layers creates essentially a mitered 90 degree angle for vapor to flow through.

This sharp angle creates drag on the vapor side resulting in liquid holdup between the packing layers, leading to premature flooding. Sulzer originally published research results on the existence of a hydraulic limit between packing layers back in 1992, but it took some years to develop a mechanical packing design that would effectively limit this occurrence. MellapakPlus accomplishes this by using a patented S shaped packing corrugation that provides a smooth vertical transition between packing layers. Other packing manufacturers have tried to copy this feature with less than optimal chamfered designs.

Subsequent tests at FRI have quantified this advantage of the S design versus the chamfered design. Specifically, results show conclusively that the MellapakPlus “S” design has a 10% advantage in efficient capacity and a 20% advantage pressure drop under normal load conditions when compared with other high capacity packings. Under highly loaded conditions, this advantage increases. In vacuum applications, where columns can get quite large and pressure drop is at a premium, this advantage is critical.

Other Considerations
Successfully designing towers with high performance packing requires the right internals and expertise, but the payout is typically quite high. High performance packings operate where other devices cannot. Sulzer’s Applications team can help evaluate all possible options and provide an optimal solution for your tower.




View More

  • Tray designs for extreme fouling applications

    Today refiners experience a lot of problems with processing of opportunity or heavy crudes. Such crudes have very high sulfur content and require the addition of amine scavengers before desalting. These amines decompose in the heater and create ammonium chlorides in the presence of water in the top of ...

  • Anti-fouling trays maximize coker main fractionator profitability

    The Coker Main Fractionator is systematically subjected to harsh operating conditions that can lead to deteriorating efficiency and performance due to coking and fouling. Poor reliability results in loss of profitable coking margins for the refinery. The main fractionator vapor feed from the coke drum ...

  • Improve separation in your column by increasing the number of trays

    Refiners often face revamp challenges when trying to improve separation within an existing column. Improving diesel recovery from gas oil, splitting benzene precursors from naphtha reformer charge, or simply minimizing product overlaps after capacity creep can all be difficult when limited by a fi xed ...

  • Gain 5-10% efficiency with this simple 4-pass tray revamp

    The design of 4-pass trays can be complex. It not only requires a close evaluation of the mechanical design but also the process response to that design at various flow rates. The balancing of the fluid flows across the tray can have a substantial effect on the tray performance, namely efficiency. Many ...

  • Proper design of mass transfer internals in the FCC flue gas scrubber can help reduce PM emissions

    The EPA’s New Source Performance Standards (40 C.F.R. §60.100-1-0, subpart Ja) regulates refinery particulate emissions, including the discharge of catalyst fines from the FCCU flue gas scrubber stack. Because refiners have traditionally correlated particulate matter (PM) emissions with FCCU ...

  • Improve fouling resistance in your wastewater benzene stripper

    Benzene stripper columns, built so that refineries can meet the National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP), operate with several unique conditions – low vapor rates, high liquid loads, and a high tendency toward fouling make designing well-balanced, effective internals difficult. The ...

  • Important tray design features that improve column operating reliability

    How often does Maintenance personnel open a column during a shutdown and find tray panels fallen without any obvious damage? How about tray valves stuck in the bottoms pump suction? While the initial reaction may be to blame faulty installation where the hardware was not properly tightened, the answer ...

  • Green design practices: focus on efficiency

    Green design is more than recycling scrap materials or calculating carbon footprints. It minimizes negative environmental impact through skillful design and operating practices to produce efficient, better-functioning processes. Because green practices reduce resource requirements, in many cases, they ...

  • 4 simple ways to convert turnarounds into profitable tower upgrade opportunities

    With planned outages commonly occurring at intervals of 2-5 years, a refinery turnaround is a prime opportunity to replace column and separator internals with the newest available technology. Planning for an outage with a “replacement-in-kind” strategy will address lost performance from refinery ...

  • Maximizing light cycle oil recovery in the FCC main fractionator

    Refiners operating FCCU's have adjusted their operating strategies to maximize light cycle oil production to meet the increased demand for automotive diesel. Catalyst formulations and reactor conditions can alter yields, but the refinery cannot take full advantage of the increased LCO recovery without ...